Bettercities

Field Notes — Better Cities

How sprawl worsens drought and how smart growth can help

Why drought hits sprawling places harder

Much of the United States has recently faced one of its worst droughts in decades, with large parts of the country in moderate-to-severe drought and corn crops in many leading states in poor condition. Drought is driven mainly by weather, and development patterns are not its cause. But the way suburbs and cities are built can make its effects heavier, mainly in two ways: through how much water households use, and through how rainwater moves across the land.

Lot size and household water use

Large-lot residential development, typical of sprawl, tends to use far more water than neighborhoods built on a more walkable scale. According to EPA research cited in the discussion, outdoor watering for lawns and landscaping can make up most residential water use in some areas. In Utah, about 60 percent of residential water went to lawns and landscaping, and households on 0.2-acre lots used roughly half as much water as those on 0.5-acre lots. In Seattle during peak season, households on 0.15-acre lots used about 60 percent less water than those on 0.37-acre lots.

A report from Western Resource Advocates, the Smart Water Report, reached similar conclusions. It pointed to Las Vegas, where shrinking average lot sizes over two decades brought a slow but steady decline in per-account water use. It pointed to Tucson, where new developments that mixed uses, raised densities, reused water and used water-efficient xeriscape landscaping showed large savings. The report concluded that water use from sprawl can be reduced by changing development density, the kind of landscape planted, and the source of irrigation water. Local zoning rules, land development standards, comprehensive plans and regional planning all shape whether that happens.

Stormwater runoff from pavement and lost groundwater

The second problem is runoff. Sprawl spreads pavement across watersheds, and rain that lands on roads, driveways and parking lots flows into streams and rivers carrying pollutants instead of soaking into the ground to recharge groundwater. EPA research cited in the article found that compact growth at about eight houses per acre reduced runoff per household by 74 percent compared with sprawling patterns of one house per acre. The main reason is simple: for the same amount of development, compact layouts need less pavement for streets, roads and parking.

A summary of research by NRDC, American Rivers and Smart Growth America estimated that recent sprawl in Atlanta, one of the fastest-sprawling metropolitan areas in the country, sends an additional 57 billion to 133 billion gallons of polluted runoff into streams and rivers each year. That water would otherwise have filtered through the soil to refill aquifers and feed underground flows to rivers, streams and lakes.

Density does not have to mean every lot is tiny. The goal is an average density, which can be reached through a mix of apartments, townhouses, small-lot homes and some larger lots. Outdoor watering is not the only issue either: in wetter regions, more efficient land use leaves more room for irrigation without harming water supplies, while in arid parts of the country household irrigation is harder to square with sustainability.

Compact development and resilient cities

Sprawl does not cause drought, and smart growth cannot end it. But both shape how well communities cope when water is short. Compact, mixed-use development and smaller lots reduce outdoor water demand and runoff, and water-efficient landscaping and reuse add to those gains. Some analysts also argue that older, post-industrial cities may be able to absorb growth more sustainably than fast-growing Sun Belt cities, because they often have greater existing water resources.

For planners, water managers and residents, the practical lesson is that land-use decisions made today affect water supply for decades. Zoning, lot sizes, landscape standards and stormwater rules are part of drought planning, not separate from it.