Bettercities

Field Notes — Better Cities

Staying in Walkable Places Built for People

Why walkable neighbourhoods make better stays

The news and opinion index of Better Cities & Towns has long argued that places matter as much as the buildings in them. Its editor, Robert Steuteville, describes placemaking as planning and development that creates places that are more than the sum of their parts. In this view, a house is more than a residential unit, a shop is more than square footage, and a street is more than a route for moving vehicles. Streets, houses and stores form communities, and communities are about people and their wellbeing.

Contributors return to the same theme in shorter comments. One writer notes that a walkable neighbourhood can tempt residents outdoors even in cold weather, while another argues that housing decisions depend on more than the unit itself, including rent, transportation costs and how close services, food and drink are. For many readers, walkability is the practical test of whether a place works.

Towns built around the village square

The publication's roots go back to New Urban News, whose first print issue appeared in May 1996, with the website following in 1999. That same month, more than 200 people, including the editor, signed the Charter of the New Urbanism. At the time, many critics dismissed the movement as folly, and some asked whether it was simply an attempt to turn back the clock to a world where people could walk to the store and meet at the village square.

The index shows how the argument has moved on. Steuteville writes that the New Urbanism has persisted and in many ways triumphed, and that professional groups including traffic engineers, builders, developers, planners and architects have been changing their practices. Contributor Scott Doyon makes a related point: New Urbanism is style neutral. Its focus is getting the urbanism right, and the architecture can take many forms.

Choosing a central base in a walkable city

Several pieces address the everyday tensions that shape walkable places. Parking remains a contentious issue, and one contributor warns that it can cloud the judgement of otherwise reasonable people. Another piece argues that incremental development by small developers focused on a single neighbourhood offers a real chance to move past the usual debates about gentrification. A further post calls for changes to street design in New York City to stop the killing of pedestrians.

The index also includes book reviews on the theme. Reviews cover Wayne Curtis's account of a 1909 walk from New York to San Francisco and Jaime Lerner's short book Urban Acupuncture, which offers a concise collection of ideas about improving cities. Readers interested in these subjects can use the index as a guide to the publication's ongoing coverage of placemaking, walkable neighbourhoods, housing and parking policy.