New Haven’s downtown is shaped by a short expressway, a federal grant and a long argument about how people should move through the center of the city. The plan to replace the Rt. 34 expressway with new streets has drawn sharp criticism from advocates of pedestrian-friendly urban design, who say the design will favor cars over walkers. This guide follows that debate and the streets and old blocks it affects.
Why the Downtown Crossing plan changes how visitors move around
The City of New Haven’s Downtown Crossing project would replace the Rt. 34 expressway with two east-west routes. The plan was produced by the consultant Parsons Brinckerhoff and is funded in part by the federal TIGER program. Critics argue that the routes contain plenty of lanes for car traffic but relatively few cross streets that would spread traffic out and make it easier for pedestrians to cross.
Opinions on the design are divided. Mayor John DeStefano Jr. has backed the scheme. John Norquist, president and CEO of the Congress for New Urbanism, called it “an eight-lane monstrosity that will be nearly impossible to cross on foot” in an opinion piece in The Hartford Courant. Norman Garrick, a University of Connecticut transportation specialist, said the planned configuration justified that description. Advocates also note a factual point: the existing expressway is depressed, not elevated.
Historic downtown blocks worth walking
Critics of the plan point out that good models of pedestrian-friendly street design already exist only a couple of blocks from the project site, in some of the most attractive older sections of downtown New Haven. Walking these blocks gives a sense of the scale and street life that the Downtown Crossing opponents want to preserve and extend into the corridor.
The debate is less about whether downtown should change and more about how closely new streets should resemble the older grid. Supporters of a different plan argue that more connected blocks would let people move between neighborhoods on foot rather than being funneled onto wide roads.
Urban renewal sites and the streets around them
The Downtown Crossing corridor sits in an area shaped by the urban renewal era. Norquist argues that the project is a chance to repair some of the damage done under former mayor Dick Lee and urban renewal chief Ed Logue, and that the current plan wastes that opportunity.
Local critics have also counted the lanes differently. Mark Abraham of the New Haven Safe Streets Coalition suggested that a sunken garage access section could push the count as high as 14 lanes. Anstress Farwell, president of the New Haven Urban Design League, said that including underground lanes serving parking brings the total to 22 lanes in one portion of the project and 26 in another. Her figures are based on the experience of a pedestrian crossing the project area diagonally.
Getting around New Haven without a car
For visitors who plan to walk, the key question is how many cross streets the final design will include. During public sessions, planners promised a substantial increase in cross streets, but the latest plan limits their number. Farwell argues that the city is building the first phase of real estate development quickly and will open only a small number of cross streets at the start, which could leave a circulation network that is hard for pedestrians to navigate.
Farwell and other critics say that building more cross streets early would let traffic disperse, which could reduce the need for some of the planned lanes. Transit improvements are another option they favor. Until the project is finished, visitors should check current street closures and crossings before planning a walking route through the corridor.