Bettercities

Field Notes — Better Cities

A new village for compact regional growth

Form Ithaca, Seth Harry and Seth Harry and Associates

This is the second in a series of articles on the Form Ithaca design charrette.

Why the Town of Ithaca is growing in compact form

The Town of Ithaca surrounds the city of Ithaca, New York. Historically it was farmland with striking natural features, including gorges and Lake Cayuga. Since the middle of the last century, about half of the town's 30 square miles has been developed with suburban-style houses, a college campus, a medical center and commercial uses.

The 2014 Comprehensive Plan calls for development in three nodes, which would help preserve the remaining farmland and natural areas. Form Ithaca worked with the town and city to draft a form-based code. During the charrette, the team demonstrated how a form-based code could work alongside smart transportation decisions in parts of both the town and the city.

Open space could be protected through policies such as transfer of development rights, combined with compact development. Mixed-use focus areas were identified across Ithaca. In the town, the study focused on the intersection of Route 96B (Danby Road) and King Road. The area currently follows an automobile-oriented pattern of development.

Form-based code and a village center at the crossroads

Form Ithaca laid out two plans, and many other layouts would be possible under a form-based code. Both place a village center at the crossroads. The second plan adds a village square. Roughly 600 homes could be built within or close to a quarter-mile radius, known as a pedshed, which is a walkable area measured from a central point.

The village square would change the character of an intersection that is now dominated by parking lots and wide pavement. The square could include the kinds of shops found in a neighborhood-serving center, perhaps 20,000 to 25,000 square feet of retail. Much of the parking could sit around the square itself, with the rest behind the buildings. Some of the shoppers could live right on the square.

The village center would not compete with downtown Ithaca, which is about two miles away. Instead, it could take some car trips off the regional road network, perhaps replacing some trips to big-box stores in the valley.

Street design for Route 96B and the walk to college

Street design is central to the village plan. The most important corridor is Route 96B, a state highway that links the proposed village with the city. Alongside it is Ithaca College, a liberal arts school with approximately 6,000 students and the second-largest employer in Ithaca. Students often walk or bike along the highway, which has no sidewalks or bike lanes. The same stretch includes a 271,000 square foot business complex with 43 firms, occupying a former factory across from the college.

Form Ithaca brought together transportation experts and stakeholders, including state Department of Transportation engineers, to address problems like those on Route 96B. The highway does not carry enough traffic to justify four lanes. The proposal narrows it to two 10-foot lanes with a boulevard strip in the middle. The road is wide enough to also accommodate a two-way cycle track and a sidewalk.

Missing middle housing in a village setting

The charrette also showed how "missing middle" housing types could fit within the village. These include courtyard cottages, townhouses and small mixed-use buildings. Simplified architecture could help make some of these units more affordable.

The plan argues that development will continue in the town, but a form-based code and supporting policies can concentrate character in a few locations. That approach would help keep the region compact while protecting its scenic and agricultural landscape.

The first article in this series covered the transformation of Route 13 from highway to boulevard. Upcoming articles are expected to address a waterfront plan, an innovation district and other topics.

The author, Robert Steuteville, is editor of Better Cities & Towns and is on the Form Ithaca team with STREAM Collaborative architects and landscape architects and Randall+West urban planners. Seth Harry and Associates, BSB Design and Alta Planning + Design also took part in the charrette.